There was this one time when my girl was working as a bartender at a bowling alley near San Francisco. She got a call from one of her friends and she said her and her boyfriend were going to come by her bar and have a *******. Her boyfriend was a pretty jealous guy, but he did have reason to be. I am already at the bar having a ******* and my girlfriend tells me they are coming by the bar shortly. I had to pretend I never met this other girl before so the boyfriend wouldn’t get pissed. The truth was, my girlfriend had introduced me to this other girl a week or two earlier. My girl and I fooled around with her one night and she ended up blowing me. Then, a few nights later they come by my apartment, and when I open the door, my gf hands me a blindfold and tells me to put it on. I do and the girls come in and my gf tells this other girl what to do to me. She ends up blowing me and then she starts fucking me and I end up cumming after a bit. I pull the blindfold off and we all relax and have a ******* or two.
Next, we have this other girl put the blindfold on and my girl and I start fucking this girl. My gf leads the show and tells me how to fuck her, what to do to her, etc. We fuck this girl for a bit, we finish, and both of the girls leave my apartment. Now, less than a week later I have to pretend to meet this girl for the first time in front of her boyfriend.
They both show up to the bar and my gf introduces me to the couple. I act like it’s the first time ever meeting this girl. Her boyfriend has no idea that we just violated this girl a few days prior. We are all getting along and having some drinks. We must have told them we were swingers and later that night we all decide to go back to my apartment. We end up making our way into my bedroom and I am fooling around with the one girl and her man is fooling around with my girl. After a few minutes I’m fucking his girl, and he is fucking mine. Both on the same bed in my room. The girl who is riding me gets off of me, pulls my condom off, then gets back on top and starts fucking me again. Pretty quickly, the guy snaps at the girl and gets pissed for fucking me with no condom. She starts saying she thought he was fucking my gf with no condom and they start to argue. We all quit fucking and this couple starts to get dressed while arguing with each other. They end up leaving my place while arguing all the way to their car. I am pretty sure I never saw that girl again.